Monthly subscription or one-time purchase: which for your app

Your audience can pay in two ways: a monthly subscription or a one-time purchase with lifetime access. You choose. The choice changes your cadence: what you publish, when, and what you announce. We compare the two with the FIFTY M demos, then give you a plan to settle it.

Julien CostaGrowth & Content Strategist, upd. , 5 min

Photo: Markus Spiske from Forchheim, Bavaria Upper Franconia, CC BY 2.0. Photo credits

A question of cadence

Behind the payment method, there is a simpler question: at what rhythm do you want to work with your audience?

With the subscription, you feed the app regularly. With the one-time purchase, you prepare everything before the opening, then the app has to stand on its own. Neither option is better. Each goes with a type of content.

Picture your audience three months from now. Do they come back every week looking for something new, or do they have all they need once the path is finished? The answer already settles a lot.

Monthly: the app must stay alive

Every month, the person pays and keeps access. In return, the app must give them a reason to come back: new content, new challenges, updates.

The option fits content that evolves: a method you enrich, a program that extends. The fitness and pilates app, with its programs and its adaptive plan, goes that way. So does the running app, with a plan recalculated according to the run.

No need to renew everything every week. A regular novelty is often enough. And each novelty gets announced in a story: that gives you something to post.

One-time purchase: everything is decided at launch

The person pays once and keeps the app. No decision to renew, no monthly payment to watch. For part of the audience, that simplicity counts.

It works when everything is ready from the start: a finished method, a path with a beginning and an end. A capsule wardrobe with its outfits and its suitcase, or a photo challenge to take on.

The downside: the app must be solid from day one. No monthly payment will fund its evolution, so it has to convince at launch.

Guitar or crochet

Say you teach guitar and your audience wants to progress week after week: chords, changes, rhythms. Every novelty gives a reason to stay, so the subscription holds up. The guitar app in our demos gathers a metronome, chord diagrams, a tuner and chord change drills.

Another case: a crochet path with patterns, counters and a yarn calculation. It is complete from the opening, and your audience mostly wants to keep it at hand. The one-time purchase seems more natural. The crochet app in our demos offers a pattern read in abbreviations or in full words, counters and a gauge calculation.

Two cases, not a rule. Only you know what your community expects.

Two ways to charge

Monthly subscription

  • A payment every month
  • For content that continues
  • The app must stay a reason to come back

One-time purchase

  • One payment with lifetime access
  • For a complete path
  • The app must be solid from the opening
On the nothing-upfront formula, we collect in both cases and our pay applies to the net.

Settling it in two sentences

First question: does your content stop or does it continue? A finished path fits the one-time purchase. Content you keep enriching fits the subscription.

Your rhythm, now. The subscription asks you to feed the app over time. The one-time purchase asks you to prepare everything before the opening. Look at your calendar: one of the two constraints will weigh on you less.

Then there is your audience. If they are used to routines and daily appointments, a subscription will often feel natural to them. If they want one precise tool, once, the one-time purchase may suit them better.

To settle it, write two sentences. What your audience gets on day one. What they get after six months. Is the second one empty? Go with the one-time purchase. Is it full of things to come? Look at the subscription.

Where it gets stuck

You choose the subscription but your calendar is full. The app stops evolving, and the person who sees the price wonders why they are paying.

You choose the one-time purchase for content you want to keep enriching. You add things without it paying off, and you have no novelty left to announce.

Last trap: the figure seen elsewhere. A price or a subscription rate heard from another creator says nothing about your audience, and no option guarantees income. The simulator on the offer page displays its assumptions: indicative simulation, not a promise.

What stays the same in both cases

On the nothing-upfront formula, we collect, we invoice, we handle support. Every subscription and every purchase shows in the shared dashboard, every month.

Our pay applies to the net: what is collected, minus VAT, payment fees, infrastructure, store commissions if any (they can go up to 30%) and refunds.

These commissions only concern sales that go through a store.

Your side of the contract

Whatever the option, your commitment on the nothing-upfront formula does not move: 1 post and 4 stories a month to talk about your app.

The option mostly changes what you talk about. The subscription gives you a novelty to announce every month. With the one-time purchase, you look for other angles: an example of use, a question from your audience.

The rest does not depend on the option either: your brand and your content stay yours, and on the nothing-upfront formula you keep an option to buy the app out, at any time. On money, our main formula is nothing upfront: you advance nothing, €0 for development, hosting and support. Development on a quote remains possible, from €15,000, with no share of the sales.

What you do this week

Monday, write your two sentences: day one, six months. Tuesday, count the new things you can add each month without forcing it.

Wednesday, open a demo close to your world on your phone. Does your content look more like a closed path or like a program that continues? Thursday, open the simulator on the offer page. It works in price per month: try the cautious setting, then the realistic one. It stays a simulation.

Friday, tell us what you offer your community. We prepare a mockup in your name, you see it, then you decide on the option. You commit only afterwards.